- Matthew Craig
- Matthew Crill
- Matthew Croft
- Matthew Cronin
- Matthew Cross
- Matthew Crow
- Matthew Crowe
- Matthew Crowl
- Matthew Culbertson
- Matthew Cumbee
- Matthew Cumming
- Matthew Cunning
- Matthew Cusick
- Matthew Cusick
- Matthew Cwiertnia
- Matthew Czyzyk
- Matthew Daffurn
- Matthew Dalton
- Matthew Dalton
- Matthew Daly
- Matthew Darch
- Matthew Darling
- Matthew Daus
- Matthew Davis
- Matthew Day
- Matthew Day
- Matthew De Jesus
- Matthew Denegre
- Matthew Denison
- Matthew Dennett
- Matthew Derr
- Matthew Devey
- Matthew Dewey
- Matthew Diamond
- Matthew DiFrancesco
- Matthew Dinneen
- Matthew Dirisio
- Matthew Dixon
- Matthew Dobbins
- Matthew Doring